Pumpkin Butter Use at the breakfast table to add true Southern flavor. Pumpkin Butter makes a great chilled pie when mixed with cream cheese and some whipped topping. Excellent on toast or biscuits. 16 oz. $8.65 Add to cart ← Cherry Butter Peach Butter → Continue shopping How to order Click on the add to cart button for each item you wish to purchase. Item quantities can be changed in the shopping cart. View cart or checkout Please note: We cannot ship to addresses outside of the continental U.S.